Is Breed Banning Going Too Far?

We’re sure that everyone has some kind of inkling as to what breed banning is, but just for those who aren’t 100% sure, it’s making owning certain breeds of dog illegal. While it’s true that there is sometimes a need for a particularly aggressive dog to be removed from a situation in which they are uncontrollable, is breed banning the solution? In order to ban a breed, all existing dogs of that breed need to be put down, even when they have done nothing wrong, which hardly seems ethical at all.

It’s true to say that there are no banned breeds in the US right now, but there are policies known as breed-specific legislation being enacted in many states, which in many ways is heading towards breed banning. The UK is one of the worst for outright bans, and it’s got people up in arms.

Is It The Owner Or The Dog?

A common question that is asked by people who are against breed banning is whether the problem is the owner or the dog. The reason that this comes up for debate is the fact that well trained dogs who have been looked after and not encouraged towards violence often are not. Even breeds that are known for being fairly aggressive are usually only this way when they are provoked.

Let’s take the Cane Corso for example. They are big dogs who have a strong bite, and if they lock onto you, you’re in trouble. But, they’re not banned even though they have a stronger bite than an alligator. It’s true to say that there are some dogs that are more aggressive than others, but a lot of this is trained into them, or they become aggressive through neglect.

Is It Fair On People Who Have Done Nothing Wrong?

The question then is whether or not breed banning and BSL are going too far. There is a difference between protecting people from aggressive animals and punishing both owners and dogs who have done nothing wrong. It seems unfair to paint a whole breed with the same brush when that’s not something that we think is right to do for humans. Everyone is different, we all have different temperaments, and the same goes for animals. 

Breed banning is not a solution, it is simply tearing away happy, healthy dogs from family members and putting them down because they have the same genetics as another dog that did attack someone. When an attack does happen though, it needs to be handled on a case by case basis, rather than focusing on what kind of dog it is. If you find yourself needing help in a case like this, get in touch with a law firm for dog attacks to get the assistance you need. The question then becomes is it fair to blame an entire breed for the fact that some people are not cut out to own dogs?

We can understand where the thought process comes from for the need for breed banning. Having said that, that’s not to say that we necessarily agree. It seems unfair to judge a whole group of dogs who have certain genetics just because there have been some that have been aggressive towards people, usually with the fault coming from the owner in the first place. 

 

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *